Compare SEO proposals on diagnosis, plan, people, reporting and terms, scored side by side, rather than on price or how polished the deck looks.

The best way to compare SEO proposals is to score each one against the same five things: how well the agency diagnosed your site, how specific the plan is, who will do the work, how results will be reported, and what the contract commits you to. Price matters, but it only means something once you know what each fee actually buys.
Most businesses get two to four proposals and end up comparing them on cost and gut feel. That’s understandable. Proposals are written to persuade, and every agency uses different headings, different metrics and different ways of describing the same work.
A simple side by side scorecard fixes that. It turns three glossy decks into one table you can discuss with your finance lead or your board, and it makes gaps obvious.
Start with the same brief for every agency
You can only compare proposals fairly if every agency answered the same question. Send one written brief with your goals, your target customers, your budget range, your timeline and any constraints (a site rebuild, a compliance sign off process, a small internal team).
If you haven’t written one yet, our guide on how to brief an SEO agency includes a template. Agencies that ignore parts of your brief are telling you something early.
The five things to score in every SEO proposal
Give each area a score from 1 to 5 and write one line explaining the score. The notes matter more than the numbers when you discuss them later.
| Area | What a strong proposal shows | What a weak one shows |
|---|---|---|
| Diagnosis | Specific findings about your site, your competitors and your search demand | Generic best practice that could apply to anyone |
| Plan | Priorities in order, with the first 90 days spelled out | A list of services with no sequence |
| People | Named people, their roles and how much time they give you | “A dedicated team” with no names |
| Reporting | Leads, revenue and visibility measures tied to your goals | Rankings and traffic only |
| Terms | Clear notice period, ownership of content and accounts | Long lock-ins and vague deliverables |
Diagnosis: did they actually look at your site?
A good proposal proves the agency has studied your business before asking for money. Look for named pages that are underperforming, specific technical problems, the search terms your buyers use and the competitors winning them.
If two proposals recommend the same thing, check whose reasoning is grounded in your data. A recommendation backed by evidence is far more likely to be right, and far easier to hold the agency to later.
Plan: is the work in a sensible order?
Strong plans say what happens first and why. Fixing crawl and indexing problems before writing new content, for example, or building pages for high intent services before chasing broad informational terms.
For B2B companies this order matters even more, because the searches that bring buyers are often low volume and easy to overlook. Our B2B SEO agency work always starts with the pages that sit closest to a sales conversation, then builds out from there.
Ask each agency what they would do in month one, month three and month six. Vague answers here usually mean the plan will be made up as you go.
People: who will do the work?
The people in the pitch meeting aren’t always the people who do the work. Ask for the names of the strategist, the writer and the technical lead on your account, and how many other clients each one handles.
A smaller team with clear ownership often outperforms a large agency where your account is one of fifty. Neither is wrong, but you should know which you’re buying.
Reporting: will you see what matters to the business?
Rankings and sessions are useful, but they aren’t the goal. A good proposal explains how the agency will connect search activity to enquiries, pipeline or sales, and how it will show progress in AI answers as well as Google results.
Ask to see a sample report. We’ve written about what a good SEO agency report should include if you want a benchmark to compare against.
Terms: what are you committing to?
Read the contract terms as carefully as the plan. Check the minimum term, the notice period, who owns the content and data, and what happens to accounts such as Search Console and analytics if you part ways.
Long lock-ins aren’t automatically bad, since SEO takes time. But a confident agency rarely needs one to keep you. Our list of SEO agency red flags covers the contract clauses worth questioning.
How to weigh price once the scores are in
Only compare fees after scoring. Then work out what each proposal costs per month of senior time, and what it would take for the work to pay for itself in leads or revenue.
- Add up each agency’s scores across the five areas.
- Remove any proposal that scores 1 or 2 on diagnosis. A weak diagnosis rarely leads to a strong result.
- For the rest, compare monthly fee against the hours and seniority included.
- Ask your top two for a short follow up call to test anything unclear.
- Pick the one you’d trust to tell you bad news early.
The cheapest proposal can be the right one, and so can the most expensive. The scorecard simply makes sure you’re paying for substance.
Questions to ask before you sign
Use the follow up call to test the proposal, not to hear the pitch again. Good questions include:
- What would you stop doing if results were slow after three months?
- Which part of this plan are you least sure about, and why?
- How will you show progress in AI search tools such as ChatGPT and Google’s AI Overviews?
- Can we speak to a current client with a similar business?
If you’d like a second opinion on proposals you’ve already received, or want to see what a diagnosis-led plan looks like for your site, book a free strategy session with our team.
Related reading: our guides to in-house SEO or an agency and how to choose a B2B SEO agency.
Common questions
What should an SEO proposal include?
A specific diagnosis of your site and competitors, a prioritised plan for the first 90 days, the named people doing the work, how results will be reported against your goals, and clear contract terms.
How many SEO proposals should I get?
Two to four is usually enough. Fewer makes comparison hard, and more tends to blur the differences and slow the decision down.
Should I choose the cheapest SEO proposal?
Only if it also scores well on diagnosis, plan, people and reporting. Compare fees after scoring, based on how much senior time and specific work each fee includes.
How long should an SEO contract be?
Many agencies ask for a minimum term because SEO takes months to show results. Check the notice period and who owns the content and accounts, and question any long lock-in without a clear reason.




